当前位置:首页>案例中心>Assignment代写案例>Assignment代写范文-Pruitt-Igoe Community

Assignment代写范文-Pruitt-Igoe Community

发布时间:2022-04-22 16:37:26 阅读:288

案例简介

  • 作者:博远教育
  • 导读:本文是一篇公共政策Assignment代写范文,本文通过对普鲁特-伊戈社区的承租人、当局和设计师的介绍,指出设计师过于关注他的建筑师同伴,而对居民关注太少。
  • 字数:1576 字
  • 预计阅读时间:4分钟

案例详情

本文是一篇公共政策Assignment代写范文,题目为:Pruitt-Igoe Community,本文通过对普鲁特-伊戈社区的承租人、当局和设计师的介绍,指出设计师过于关注他的建筑师同伴,而对居民关注太少。

普鲁特-伊戈社区

In the name of urban renewal, large-scale removal of slums in cities and the construction of high-level affordable housing were going on in the 20th century America. Many projects eventually became areas of poverty, high crime rates, and chaotic environment. Among them, the Pruitt-Igoe community in St. Louis Missouri is a representative case. The reason for the failure of a large number of public housing projects in the United States was once thought to be a problem with the architectural design of these houses. Through the introduction of the Pruitt-Igoe community's renters, authorities, and designers, this paper points out that the designer had focused too much on his fellow architects and too little on the residents. Urban planning should not only design affordable housing communities in terms of spatial forms and architectural forms, but also examine how public housing planning and construction can be combined with good social and ecological development to promote community harmony.

在20世纪的美国,以城市更新的名义,大规模拆除城市中的贫民窟,建造高级经济适用房。许多项目最终成为贫困、高犯罪率和混乱环境的地区。其中,密苏里州圣路易斯的普鲁特-伊戈社区就是一个典型案例。美国大量公共住房项目失败的原因一度被认为是这些房屋的建筑设计问题。本文通过介绍普鲁特-伊戈社区的租客、当局和设计师,指出设计师过于关注他的建筑师同伴,而对居民关注太少。城市规划不仅要从空间形式和建筑形式上设计经济适用房社区,还要研究如何将公共住房规划和建设与良好的社会和生态发展相结合,促进社区和谐。

Renters of the Pruitt-Igoe community were mainly the working-class and submerged middle-class in the city. During the 20th century, major cities in the United States experienced rapid industrialization. The slums in urban centers often had high living densities and poor environments, and are considered to be ugly scars in the city. Public Housing was invested and built by the government and targeted low- and middle-income people to solve the housing problems of low-income groups in the city. Another purpose of public housing construction is to attract the middle class to live in the city center, so as to restore the vitality of the urban center area. Yamasaki adopted a uniform layout method in the general plan layout under the limitation of the number of buildings. The purpose of not stopping elevators at all floors (only the first, fourth, seventh, and tenth floors) is to promote the socializing of residents in high-rise buildings. Setting up elevators to stop at only specific floors can increase the chances of meeting and communicating with neighbors and establish a good neighborhood relationship. Public service facilities such as galleries, laundry rooms and storage rooms have been designed on the floor where the elevators are parked, creating a community space for public communication and activities. This can turn each building in a residential area into a life-style community with close neighborhoods.

The Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) is a specialized agency responsible for the construction and management of public housing. From the perspective of saving construction funds, HUD required all 33 buildings of the project to have 11 floors. During the construction of the Pruitt-Igoe community, HUD strictly controlled the cost. Many convenience facilities (such as children's playgrounds, green areas, and public toilets on the ground floor) that were designed to promote linkages and activities among residents were canceled, and materials for building public facilities were also based on the lowest standard. After the completion of the community, a large number of outdoor public facilities in the original program design to promote neighborhood communication were not implemented at all. Only the most basic two innovative designs were still completed. In 1955, 33 buildings in the Pruitt-Igoe community were completed. Although the budget was continuously controlled during construction, the total cost was still 60% higher than the initial budget. After its completion, the Pruitt-Igoe community has become the tallest building complex in the region, and it is completely different from the surrounding architectural styles. Yamasaki's design uses a very pure modernist architectural style. The facade is simple, unadorned, functional, and uniform. The large-scale high-rise buildings and the surrounding low-rise buildings have formed a huge contrast in image, which has become one of the reasons why the design of the Pruitt-Igoe community was widely criticized in the future.

Avant-grand architects of social housing in western Europe were already working on similar projects, and Yamasaki wanted to follow their steps and create something even better. Initially, part of the architectural community though very highly of Yamasaki’s work. However, that was before everything fell apart and the neighborhood deteriorated. The later demolition of the Pruitt-Igoe community was considered by the architecture community as a sign of the decline of modernism. Architects nowadays believe that the Pruitt-Igoe community has concentrated on the shortcomings of modernist architectural styles: uniform, monotonous and indifferent, lack of human touch. As time goes by, people think of the reason why the Pruitt-Igoe community was demolished, and generally think that the irrationality of the architectural design resulted in the failure of the Pruitt-Igoe community. Oscar Newman detailed analysis of architectural design issues in the Pruitt-Igoe community in his Creating Defensible Space. The problems include lack of protection and defense in the public promenade space. It was in an unsupervised state, and it was easy to induce criminal events. The entrance to the community's internal buildings was facing a large area of public activity, so anyone could freely enter the buildings, including criminals who attacked the tenants in the elevators. This further deepens the impression that architectural design issues have caused the decline of the Pruitt-Igoe community, but essentially, it was Yamasaki’s failure to think from the authorities and the renters’ perspectives.

In conclusion, Minoru Yamasaki satisfied the architect the most in the design, at least the ones in his own era. He has failed to approach the project from a more practical perspective, failing to consider the profound effect of government budget and neighborhood management issues. The Pruitt-Igoe residential area is a design where functionalism went to extremes. In fact, European countries and US built a large number of such buildings in the 1950s and 1960s, causing widespread social problems. The destruction of Pruitt-Igoe residential area became a watershed between modernism and postmodernism. This event reminds every designer that the quality of design depends not only on the form of design, but also on the users, supervisors, and sponsors. While users are always the top priority for designers, failing to balance user needs with financing and regulation would only lead to failed projects.

总之,山崎实实在设计上最让建筑师满意,至少是在他自己的时代。他未能从更实际的角度来看待这个项目,未能考虑到政府预算和社区管理问题的深远影响。普鲁特伊戈住宅区是一个功能主义走向极端的设计。事实上,欧洲国家和美国在20世纪50年代和60年代建造了大量此类建筑,造成了广泛的社会问题。普鲁特·伊戈住宅区的破坏成为现代主义和后现代主义之间的分水岭。本次活动提醒每一位设计师,设计的质量不仅取决于设计的形式,还取决于用户、主管和赞助商。虽然用户始终是设计师的首要任务,但如果不能在用户需求与融资和监管之间取得平衡,只会导致项目失败。

以上就是本篇Essay范文全部内容,欢迎阅读,范文内容和格式仅供留学生参考学习,不得抄袭,如有Essay代写需要,请咨询网站客服。

其他案例